Supreme Court Nominations, 1789 to 2020: Actions by the Senate, the Judiciary Committee, and the President

"The procedure for appointing a Justice to the Supreme Court of the United States is provided for by the Constitution in only a few words. The “Appointments Clause” (Article II, Section 2, clause 2) states that the President “shall nominate, and by and with the Advice and Consent of the Senate, shall appoint ... Judges of the supreme Court.” The process of appointing Justices has undergone changes over two centuries, but its most basic feature—the sharing of power between the President and Senate—has remained unchanged. To receive a lifetime appointment to the Court, a candidate must first be nominated by the President and then confirmed by the Senate. An important role also has come to be played midway in the process (after the President selects, but before the Senate considers) by the Senate Judiciary Committee.

On rare occasions, Presidents also have made Supreme Court appointments without the Senate’s consent, when the Senate was in recess. Such “recess appointments,” however, were temporary, with their terms expiring at the end of the Senate’s next session. The last recess appointments to the Court were made in the 1950s.

The need for a Supreme Court nomination arises when a vacancy occurs or is scheduled to occur on the Court.1 The most recent Court vacancy to be included in this report was created by the death of Ruth Bader Ginsburg on September 18, 2020. In response to Justice Ginsburg’s death, on September 29, 2020, President Donald Trump nominated Amy Coney Barrett, a sitting judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, to replace Justice Ginsburg. It was the 164 th time a President of the United States has nominated someone to be a Supreme Court Justice.

The Barrett nomination received four days of confirmation hearings, after which the Senate Judiciary Committee, on October 22, 2020, by a vote of 12-0, favorably reported the nomination to the Senate. The committee vote on the Barrett nomination was boycotted by the 10 Democratic Senators on the committee, resulting in the absence of recorded “nay” votes on the nomination. Following three days of floor debate and a 51-48 vote, on October 25, to close debate on the nomination, the Senate, on October 26, confirmed Judge Barrett to the Court, by a 52-48 vote.

In the past, most, but not all, Supreme Court nominations have received Senate confirmation. From the first appointments in 1789, the Senate has confirmed 127 out of 164 Court nominations. Of the 37 unsuccessful nominations, 11 were rejected in Senate roll-call votes, while most of the rest, in the face of committee or Senate opposition to the nominee or the President, were withdrawn by the President, or were postponed, tabled, or never voted on by the Senate. The 37 unconfirmed nominations, however, included those of six individuals who were later renominated and confirmed.."
Supreme Court Nominations